First Flytying Contest Voting

RWFF game announcements and discussion (off-topic posts will be deleted)

Moderators: Scottish Warrior, Yellowstone7, richwest, Pitti

First Flytying Contest Voting

Postby Pitti » Mon Feb 25, 2008 10:22 am

Hello :)

Thanks to all participants. Believe it or not, we got 2(!) entries.
So this is the first and last contest in this vein.

Now it's time for the public voting at the forum.

For every category we use a scala from 1 to 10, in which 10 is the best.

Please vote for 6 flies. Every fly, excepting the freestile has 3 categories:

1) Proportion: How close is the pattern related to the original? Every part-size relative to the other parts, e.g. are the wings ok or too long?

2) Colors: How correct are colors of the fly compare with the original?

3) Completeness: How complete is the fly? Are all parts included?

The Freestile Fly has only one category:

1) How beautiful are the patterns?

@ The creators of the flies: Please do not vote. Thx :)

Please copy and paste the lines below into your reply and add only the values:

==============================================
***********************************************************

Kate1:
Proportion =
Colors =
Completeness =

Kate2:
Proportion =
Colors =
Completeness =

Lee Blue1:
Proportion =
Colors =
Completeness =

Lee Blue2:
Proportion =
Colors =
Completeness =

Pride:
Prettiness =

Floodtide:
Prettiness =

***********************************************************
==============================================

The voting runs till next sunday 3.2.08 12pm. Then it will be calculate and the result will posted here.

Hopefully we get sometimes a new RWFF-Flytying tool which support higher resolutions. Then the flies would look stunning. :)

Regards Peter


Image
User avatar
Pitti
 
Posts: 484
Joined: Thu Mar 15, 2007 10:59 am
Location: Berlin

Postby taupo_tiger » Mon Feb 25, 2008 2:49 pm

hello,
here are the votes of the Austrian jury:
:D

Kate1:
Proportion = 9
Colors = 7
Completeness =7

Kate2:
Proportion = 8
Colors = 8
Completeness = 8

Lee Blue1:
Proportion = 9
Colors = 6
Completeness = 7

Lee Blue2:
Proportion = 8
Colors = 8
Completeness = 9

Pride:
Prettiness = 8

Floodtide:
Prettiness = 10


all the best,
martin
:)
User avatar
taupo_tiger
 
Posts: 224
Joined: Mon Jun 11, 2007 10:32 am
Location: austria

Postby Boston Bob » Thu Feb 28, 2008 1:41 am

Here's my score from Boston:
Great job by both contestants. You should both be proud.
Boston Bob

Kate1:
Proportion = 9
Colors = 8
Completeness = 7

Kate2:
Proportion = 9
Colors = 7
Completeness = 9

Lee Blue1:
Proportion = 10
Colors = 9
Completeness = 9

Lee Blue2:
Proportion = 8
Colors = 7
Completeness = 8

Pride:
Prettiness = 10

Floodtide:
Prettiness = 10
Fishing isn't all I do, but it's what I like to do best !
User avatar
Boston Bob
 
Posts: 319
Joined: Wed Dec 27, 2006 10:48 am
Location: Watertown, Ma.

Postby Fishin Musician » Thu Feb 28, 2008 2:19 am

Nice work!

Kate1:
Proportion = 10
Colors = 8
Completeness = 8

Kate2:
Proportion = 10
Colors = 7
Completeness = 9

Lee Blue1:
Proportion = 10
Colors = 10
Completeness = 9

Lee Blue2:
Proportion = 10
Colors = 8
Completeness = 8

Pride:
Prettiness = 10

Floodtide:
Prettiness = 10
User avatar
Fishin Musician
 
Posts: 99
Joined: Wed Aug 22, 2007 2:16 am
Location: Old Forge, PA

Postby oppimax » Thu Feb 28, 2008 9:53 pm

Hi,
I'm not an expert but I try to give a vote...

Kate1:
Proportion = 8
Colors = 8
Completeness = 8

Kate2:
Proportion = 9
Colors = 8
Completeness = 9

Lee Blue1:
Proportion = 8
Colors = 9
Completeness = 9

Lee Blue2:
Proportion = 9
Colors = 7
Completeness = 8

Pride:
Prettiness = 9

Floodtide:
Prettiness = 10

btw: I would pay for knowing how to create those masterpieces! :wink:

Big congrats to all! :D

Ciao
Massimo
User avatar
oppimax
 
Posts: 241
Joined: Thu Aug 31, 2006 9:50 am
Location: Genova - Italy


Return to Real World Fly Fishing

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 5 guests

cron